There is a difference whether you and/or your team stands with the Closed Foot Method or Traditional Method and not just visually.
There are two ways of standing at Attention for the American military, drill teams and honor guards when referring to the position of the feet (the star is the center of balance):
Closed-Foot Method | Traditional Method |
Which position is better?
The Closed-Foot Method creates a clean line and helps the honor guard member to balance all of their weight on the whole of both feet and bring the center of balance (the star) centered between the feet.
The Traditional Method, places more pressure on the heels and up through the spine. Subsequently, standing for longer periods can become quite difficult/painful.
When I teach, I show the difference between the two stances to each trainee from the side: stand using the Traditional Method and then, without moving your upper body, move to the Closed-Foot Method. As your center of gravity moves forward, those observing will see your upper body shift forward about two inches! Much more comfortable than an aching spine.
Comments 4
I prefer closed, not only because it supports the spine better, but also because it enables a cleaner step-off. The open toed position requires extra attention to the method used to (A) shift the weight from the heels to the center of gravity and (B) rotate the foot and leg forward on the first step. I guarantee you that if a team doesn’t have a technique to deal with those two things, their step-offs are not going to be precise, and some of their members are going to have turned out feet for the first, and maybe second step. It looks sloppy to me.
Author
Hello Frances,
Thank you for commenting on this article. I too prefer the Closed Foot Method and for the reasons you describe as well. All kinds of marching units can benefit from this method of standing at Attention.
DrillMaster
The fact that we know that this posture cannot be comfortable for military members, it shocks me to see that it’s still in effect with my son in boot camp. Knowing that he has had some issues as a teenager with his spine, made me think about this. We have degenerative spinal issues in our family, and this stance looks uncomfortable. It does not look like a readiness stance. It looks unnatural and uncomfortable surprised it’s still being used. Are all drill instructors taught that this stance may not be the best physically? That it made you damage over time?
Author
Ma’am,
We are not taught about the best posture and instructors are not schooled in identifying disfunction. That is left to the medical professionals in the MEPS process. If an individual makes it through MEPS, he/she is medically qualified to endure Basic Training/Boot Camp and training beyond that.